Truer words were never spoke. We are forced to conclude he does not know how to use the French phrase he deploys so snappily.
The debate over whether or not addiction is a disease or some other type of involuntary behavior versus a pattern of freely chosen behavior can get crazy. The rhetoric from the pro-disease side has been rife with emotional pleas that paint anyone who thinks otherwise as a big mean crazy crackpot who hates everyone.
But the fact is that the science is not settled in favor of the disease model of addiction, and there are plenty of classically Fallacious to reputable essay sources who will attest to this fact.
I will add to it over time, and since I get many requests for info from students, I hope this page can serve as a great reference source for those looking for credible opinions on the non-disease choice side of the great debate about the nature of addiction.
Again this page is a source for quotations from the opinion that addiction is not a disease — and that it is something else, perhaps a freely chosen pattern of behavior.
Addiction Is Not A Disease Although the brain disease model of addiction is perceived by many as received knowledge it is not supported by research or logic.
In contrast, well established, quantitative choice principles predict both the possibility and the details of addiction. Theory and New Data. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 4. PDF Pathology, as revolutionized by Rudolf Virchowrequires an identifiable alteration in bodily tissue, a change in the cells of the body, for disease classification.
No such identifiable pathology has been found in the bodies of heavy drinkers and drug users.
This alone justifies the view that addiction is not a physical disease Szasz ; The stomach is an important part of the story. And so with addiction.
The neural events in VTA clearly belong to the underlying mechanisms of addiction. They are necessary, but not sufficient; they are only part of the story. Retrieved April 4,from http: An addiction does not mean that God in heaven decided which people are alcoholics and addicts.
There is no biological urge to form addictions, one that we will someday find under a microscope and that will finally make sense of all these different cravings and idiocies such as exercising to the point of injury or having sex with people who are bad for you.
What do you think about the idea that addiction is a progressive incurable brain disease?
I wrote a paper back in that systematically reviewed the brain findings in people who use methamphetamines for extended periods of time. They met the criteria for addiction and all of these things, and could not find this sort of pathological brain structure or measures that people had been talking about.Online Library of Liberty.
A collection of scholarly works about individual liberty and free markets. A project of Liberty Fund, Inc. Describes and gives examples of logical fallacies from the media and everyday life, applying logic to controversial issues in order to improve critical thinking skills.
A science presenter, writer, speaker & former TV host; author of The Skeptic's Handbook (over , copies distributed & available in 15 languages).
Explosive: A Review Of Fake Medical Tests March 5 | From: JonRappoport Over the years, during my investigations of deep fraud, I’ve uncovered very popular medical diagnostic tests that are wrong-headed, misleading, and fallacious.
Arguments we think creationists should NOT use Table of contents. Which arguments should definitely not be used?; Darwin recanted on his deathbed; Moon-Dust thickness proves a young moon. With the recent publication of PHYSICS IS there are now three Ask the Physicist books!
Click on the book images below for information on the content of the books and for information on ordering.